2006
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Stacy L. Leeds, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins
2007
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins, Troy Wayne Poteete
2008
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins, Troy Wayne Poteete
2009
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins, Troy Wayne Poteete
2010
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins, Troy Wayne Poteete
2011
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins, Troy Wayne Poteete
2012
Darell R. Matlock, Jr., Chief Justice, Darrell R. Dowty, James G. Wilcoxen, Kyle B. Haskins[1], Troy Wayne Poteete, John C. Garrett[2]
2013
Darrell R. Dowty, Chief Justice, Troy Wayne Poteete, John C. Garrett, James G. Wilcoxen, Angela Jones
2014
Darrell R. Dowty, Chief Justice, Troy Wayne Poteete, John C. Garrett, James G. Wilcoxen, Angela Jones
2015
Troy Wayne Poteete, Chief Justice, John C. Garrett, James G. Wilcoxen, Angela Jones, Lynn Burris
2016
Troy Wayne Poteete, Chief Justice, John C. Garrett, James G. Wilcoxen, Angela Jones, Lynn Burris
2017
John C. Garrett, Chief Justice, James G. Wilcoxen, Angela Jones, Lynn Burris, Mark L. Dobbins
2018
John C. Garrett, Chief Justice, James G. Wilcoxen, Angela Jones[3], Lynn Burris, Mark L. Dobbins, Lee W. Paden[4]
2019
James G. Wilcoxen, Chief Justice, Lee W. Paden, Lynn Burris, Mark L. Dobbins, John C. Garrett
2020
James G. Wilcoxen, Chief Justice, Lee W. Paden, Lynn Burris[5], Mark L. Dobbins, John C. Garrett, Shawna S. Baker[6]
2021
Lee W. Paden, Chief Justice, Shawna S. Baker, Mark L. Dobbins, John C. Garrett, Rex Earl Starr
2022
John C. Garrett, Chief Justice, Lee W. Paden, Shawna S. Baker, Mark L. Dobbins, Rex Earl Starr
2023
John C. Garrett, Chief Justice, Lee W. Paden, Shawna S. Baker, Mark L. Dobbins, Rex Earl Starr
[1] Resigned effective June 1st, 2012
[2] Confirmed by Cherokee Nation Tribal Council on June 12th, 2012
[3] Passed away July 31, 2018
[4] Confirmed by Cherokee Nation Tribal Council on September 27, 2018
[5] Passed away March 12, 2020
[6] Confirmed by Cherokee Nation Tribal Council on August 27, 2020